Wellow Parish Council
Clerk
Geoff White
Myrtle
Cottage, Wellow, BA2 8QS
Tel: 01225 830159
Minutes of a extraordinary meeting
of the Parish Council held on Thursday, February 7th 2013 at 8pm in
the Village Hall.
Present:
CllrsAndrews, Betts, Caudle, Clarkson, Doman, Karthauser, Prentice, Wheeler and
White along with some twentyfivemembers of the public. District Cllr Neil
Butters and Peter Duppa-Miller were present as observers.
Agenda:
13.EM1 To
accept apologies for absence
None
13.EM2 Declarations of interest in any
matters on theagenda
None
13.EM3 Wellow Sports Proposal
The Chair presented a brief history
of the proposal to build tennis courts and other sports facilities on Wellow
Playing Field.
The idea
originated in December 2011, with extensive consultation during the latter part
of 2012 which included an open day and a public meeting.
A proposal
was brought to the Parish Council by the Wellow Sports Group (WSG)in December
2012.
Councillors
worked over the Christmas period to inform themselves about the merits of the
proposals, and about resident’s concerns – drainage, Magic Box, lighting,
funding, long term sustainability etc .
Some
Councillors visited Freshford at night to look at the lighting installed there.
Councillors
discussed the issues that concerned residents, and defined 7 conditions that
the Parish Council would impose – these conditions will mitigate residents’
concerns.
The Parish
Council received letters supporting the proposals and a petition signed by 98
residents who were opposed to the idea.
At the
December meeting, the intention was that the Parish Council would make a
decision at the January meeting. By the January meeting, Councillors had
established for themselves their views on the matter, and recognised that there
was a significant number of residents who opposed the proposals as well as a
significant number supporting it.
At the
January meeting, the Council ratified the 7 conditions that the Parish Council
will impose. Because of the depth of feeling that this issue has caused, at
that meeting Councillors took the decision to put the proposal to a referendum
– formally a “village survey”. The Parish Council chose to include residents
aged 16 and over, instead of just those 18 and over. The Parish Council put in
place a mechanism so that all residents could vote, even if they could not
actually get to the village hall on the Saturday. The referendum was not
allowed to be binding on the Parish Council, but the Councillors would place
“great weight” on the result.
The
referendum was held on January 26th 2013. The Chair expressed his thanks to Alex
Martin, who dealt with votes cast by those unable to attend on the day, to
everyone who voted, and to the Clerk and Peter Duppa-Miller who ran the
referendum on the day.
323
residents voted – about 77% of those eligible to vote. This is an exceptionally
high turnout, which gives a strong mandate to the Council. The result was 198 votes in favour, 118
against and 7 from voters who were still unsure. About 100 residents did not
vote.
While there
is a significant majority in support of the proposal, it concerns Councillors
that there are residents who are opposed to it, and in taking this forward, the
Parish Council must ensure that the project is for the whole community.
The Chair asked Councillors if they
had any comments to make before taking a vote – none did.
The Clerk put the proposal to the
Council, “Does the Parish Council support the proposal, subject to the 7
conditions?”
The result was 6 votes in favour and
3 against. There were no abstentions.
The proposal was carried.
The Chair said that, having voted to
support the Sports proposals, the Council now had to decide how they wanted to
manage the process to ensure the project was a success for the whole community.
He suggested that there were three
options:
Option 1: Do Councillors just want
to monitor progress, asking WSG to proceed but reporting back to the Council?
Option 2: Do Councillors want to
join the WSG to create a project management group?
Option 3: Do Councillors want to
take the lead in driving this project to a successful conclusion?
Cllr Wheeler said he favoured the
second option, as did Cllr Clarkson who suggested that young people should also
join the project management group.
Cllrs Karthauser and Andrews said
that there should be representatives from The Parish Council representing both
sides, ie those in favour and those against.
Cllr Caudle said that she could not see how a Councillor could be on the
project management group if they opposed it.
Cllr White said that, having voted
in favour of the proposal, the Council must ensure the success of the project.
Cllr Doman asked for an assurance
that the whole Parish Council would retain oversight of the progress to meet
the conditions. The Chair confirmed that this would be the case, but said that
we were not prescribing how the project management group would work, so we
would not necessarily expect an update at every Council meeting. The process of
sourcing funding, going through planning etc may take many months.
Cllr Betts wanted to know why an
extraordinary meeting of the Parish Council had been called rather than
addressing this Sports issue at the next scheduled meeting. The Chair said that he had received apologies
from two Councillors for the February 11th meeting. Given the
significance of the Sports issue, he felt that all Councillors should be
present, and had called this meeting.
The Chair proposed that the Parish
Council adopt Option 2. The voting was 6
in favour, none against but 3 abstentions.
Thus, it was agreed to accept Option 2.
Cllr Doman said that, as a first
step, we should ask WSG for a business plan.
Cllr Betts agreed. Cllr Betts said that she was against the proposal to
build two tennis courts with flood lighting. Cllr Caudle wanted to be sure that
the Lawn Tennis Association would not fund a single court. She had written to
the LTA, and received a reply, as follows: “… if the club decides to only
construct one court without floodlights they are likely to be able to fund this
without requiring LTA funding.”
Cllr Clarkson stressed that the
proposal had been for two courts, and the majority were in favour. Cllr
Karthauser said that we don’t know at this stage whether two courts are achievable,
as there are many hurdles to get over, not least finding the funding.
Cllr Andrews suggested that a group
be set up to oversee the whole field – including the Village hall and
children’s play area, as well as the sports, to ensure the best collective
approach.
Cllr Caudle said that she would like
to see a blank sheet at this stage. Cllr White pointed out that anyone could
have come forward with an alternative plan during the consultation period, but
that nobody had done so.
The Chair said that the proposal put
to the referendum was for two courts, and other sports. There was a significant
majority in support of the proposals, and that is what residents expect to be
delivered.
The Chair asked each Councillor
whether they would like to support the WSG in taking the proposal forward, and
in making this a successful project for the whole community. Cllrs Andrews, Clarkson and Wheeler said that
they would like to. Cllr Karthauser said that he was interested but unsure as
to whether he could commit much time. Cllrs Caudle, Betts and Doman said they did not have the time. Cllr White regretfully
declined because of family commitments.
The Chair proposed that Cllrs
Andrews, Clarkson and Wheeler would join the WSG and that Cllr Karthauser could
act in support as and when he could. The
voting was 6 in favour, none against but 3 abstentions. The Chair asked
Councillors for an alternative way forward that was better, and that would get
unanimous support. None was put forward, and the three Councillors who had
abstained agreed the proposal for Cllrs Andrews, Clarkson and Wheeler to join
the WSG, with Cllr Karthauser supporting when he could, was the best way
forward.
13.EM4 Date
of next meeting
It was confirmed that the next
meeting would be on Monday, February 11th at 8pm in the Village
Hall.
There being no further business the
meeting was adjourned at 8.45pm.
Geoffrey White
Parish Clerk
February 10th 2013